What Does Porter's Five Forces Mean in Marketing?

In marketing, The Five Forces Model (5 Forces), developed by Michael Porter, is a framework used to analyse the competitive rivalry and dynamics of an industry. It helps businesses understand the competitive forces at play and assess the attractiveness of an industry for profitability.

What Are the 5 Forces?

The Five Forces model consists of these elements:

1 Threat of New Entrants

This element assesses the potential for new competitors to enter the industry. It considers factors such as entry barriers, economies of scale, access to distribution channels, government regulations, and brand loyalty. A high threat of new entrants puts pressure on existing players and reduces industry profitability.

2 Bargaining Power of Suppliers

This element examines the influence and leverage that suppliers have over the industry (supplier power). It considers factors such as the concentration of suppliers, availability of substitute inputs, switching costs, and the uniqueness of supplier products or services. Suppliers with higher bargaining power can demand better terms, increase prices, or limit the availability of inputs, which can impact industry profitability.

3 Bargaining Power of Buyers

This element focuses on the influence and power of customers in the industry. Factors considered include buyer concentration, buyer switching costs, price sensitivity, and the availability of substitute products or services. Buyers with higher bargaining power can negotiate for lower prices, better terms, or higher quality, which can affect industry profitability.

4 Threat of Substitute Products or Services

This element examines the availability and attractiveness of alternative products or services that can fulfill the same customer needs. It considers factors such as price-performance trade-offs, customer switching costs, and the level of product differentiation. The presence of viable substitutes can limit the pricing power and profitability of existing industry players.

5 Intensity of Competitive Rivalry

This element assesses the level of competition among existing industry players. Factors considered include the number and diversity of competitors, industry growth rate, product differentiation, and exit barriers. High levels of rivalry can result in price wars, increased marketing efforts, and reduced profitability.

By evaluating these forces, businesses can understand the key factors shaping their industry's competitiveness, identify threats and opportunities, and develop effective strategies to achieve a sustainable competitive advantage.

"Porter's Five Forces Model is a powerful framework for analysing industry competition - yet very few businesses use it. By assessing threat of new entrants, supplier and buyer bargaining power, substitute threats, and competitive rivalry, boardroom executives can make informed strategic decisions that can build a stronger competitive advantage."

Paul Mills
CEO & Founder, VCMO

What Is the Purpose of Porter's 5 Forces?

Businesses can use the Five Forces Model in various contexts to help make informed strategic decisions. Here are some common contexts where the model can be applied:

• Industry Analysis: The Five Forces Model is widely used to conduct an industry analysis. It helps businesses understand the competitive landscape, identify the key forces influencing industry profitability, and assess the attractiveness of the industry. This analysis can assist in determining market entry strategies, evaluating the potential for growth, and understanding the competitive threats faced by the business.
• Strategic Planning: The Five Forces Model is employed during strategic planning processes to inform decision-making. By assessing the five forces, businesses can identify areas of competitive advantage, potential risks, and opportunities. It guides the formulation of marketing strategies to enhance competitiveness, differentiate from rivals, and capture market share. The model helps businesses align their strategies with the external market dynamics and make informed choices about resource allocation and investment priorities.
• Market Entry Decisions: When considering entering a new market or industry, businesses can use the Five Forces Model to evaluate the barriers to entry, competitive intensity, and the overall attractiveness of the market. It assists in understanding the level of competition, the bargaining power of suppliers and buyers, and the potential threats from new entrants and substitute products. This analysis aids in making informed decisions about market entry strategies, resource allocation, and risk assessment.
• Competitive Analysis: The Five Forces Model serves as a valuable tool for analysing the competitive landscape within an industry. It helps businesses understand the positions and strategies of key competitors, assess their strengths and weaknesses, and identify potential areas of competitive advantage. This analysis can guide businesses in developing strategies to differentiate themselves, respond to competitive threats, and capture market share.
• Mergers and Acquisitions: The Five Forces model is often used in the context of mergers and acquisitions (M&A) to assess the attractiveness and risks associated with an industry. It helps potential acquirers evaluate the competitive environment, understand the bargaining power of suppliers and buyers, and assess the potential for future profitability. This analysis aids in making informed decisions about M&A opportunities, valuations, and integration strategies.

In summary, the Five Forces Model is a versatile tool that businesses use in various contexts. It provides a structured framework for understanding the external market dynamics and making informed strategic choices.

An Example of Porter's 5 Forces Analysis – Airline Industry.

Here’s how a Five Forces analysis might look for a company operating in the airline industry:

• Threat of New Entrants: The airline industry has relatively high barriers to entry, including significant capital requirements for aircraft, infrastructure, and operational costs. Additionally, there are regulatory hurdles, limited access to airport slots, and established brand loyalty. This creates a moderate threat of new entrants.
• Bargaining Power of Suppliers: Aircraft manufacturers, fuel suppliers, and labour unions exert significant influence on airlines. Suppliers, such as Boeing or Airbus, have a relatively high bargaining power due to the specialized nature of their products. Fuel prices and availability can also impact profitability. Labour unions can negotiate for favourable terms and affect operational costs. Overall, suppliers hold a considerable degree of power in the airline industry.
• Bargaining Power of Buyers: Customers in the airline industry have moderate to high bargaining power. They have access to a wide range of airline choices, and the internet has made it easier for customers to compare prices and services. Switching costs for customers are relatively low, and they can demand competitive prices, better services, and more amenities.
• Threat of Substitute Products or Services: The airline industry faces some threats from substitute modes of transportation, such as trains, buses, and cars for shorter distances. However, for long-distance travel, especially across continents or oceans, air travel remains the most efficient option. Thus, the threat of substitutes is relatively moderate.
• Intensity of Competitive Rivalry: The airline industry is highly competitive, with numerous players vying for market share. Airlines compete on various factors, including price, service quality, routes, and frequent flyer programs. Price wars and fierce competition can lead to reduced profitability. Intense competition is driven by factors like low differentiation among services and high fixed costs.

What Are the Advantages of Porter's Five Forces Model?

The Five Forces Model offers several advantages for businesses and strategic decision-making:

1. Industry Analysis: The model provides a structured framework for analysing the competitive dynamics of an industry. It helps businesses understand the key forces at play and their impact on industry profitability. This analysis assists in assessing the attractiveness of an industry and identifying opportunities and threats.
2. Strategic Planning: The Five Forces model helps businesses in strategic planning by providing insights into the external market environment. It assists in identifying areas of competitive advantage, potential risks, and market trends. This information guides the development of strategies that align with the external forces and enhance the organisation's competitiveness.
3. Competitive Positioning: By analysing the five forces, businesses can understand their competitive position within the industry. It helps identify the relative strengths and weaknesses compared to competitors, allowing businesses to develop strategies that leverage their advantages and mitigate weaknesses. This analysis aids in making informed decisions about differentiation, pricing, and market positioning.
4. Risk Assessment: The model enables businesses to assess and anticipate potential risks and threats in the industry. By understanding the competitive forces, businesses can identify potential challenges, such as new entrants, supplier or buyer power, substitute products, or intense rivalry. This helps businesses proactively address risks and develop contingency plans.
5. Strategic Decision-Making: The Five Forces model provides a systematic approach to strategic decision-making. It helps businesses evaluate different options, such as market entry, expansion, or diversification, based on the competitive forces at play. By considering the potential impact of each force on the business, organizations can make more informed and data-driven decisions.

Overall, the advantages of the Five Forces model lie in its ability to provide a structured analysis of the competitive environment, support strategic planning and decision-making, identify opportunities and risks, and assist businesses in positioning themselves effectively within their industry.

What Are the Disadvantages of Porter's Five Forces Model?

While the Five Forces model offers valuable insights, it is important to be aware of its limitations and potential disadvantages:

1. Simplified Analysis: The Five Forces Model provides a simplified view of the complex dynamics within an industry. It focuses primarily on five key forces and may overlook other influential factors, such as technological advancements, regulatory changes, or cultural shifts. Businesses should supplement the model with additional tools and frameworks to gain a comprehensive understanding of their industry.
2. Lack of Quantitative Analysis: The Five Forces Model relies on qualitative analysis rather than quantitative data. It does not provide specific metrics or numerical assessments of the forces. As a result, it can be challenging to precisely measure the impact and magnitude of each force, making it harder to prioritize actions or compare across different industries.
3. Limited Focus on Opportunities: While the Five Forces Model identifies threats and challenges, it may not adequately emphasize opportunities within the industry. The model's primary focus is on the competitive landscape and may not explicitly highlight potential areas for growth, innovation, or strategic partnerships. Businesses should complement the model with other tools to capture a broader perspective on opportunities.
4. Static Analysis: The Five Forces Model provides a snapshot of the industry's competitive dynamics at a given point in time. However, industries are dynamic and continually evolving. Factors such as market trends, technological advancements, or shifts in consumer behavior can quickly change the competitive landscape. Regular updates and ongoing analysis are necessary to account for these changes.
5. Lack of Guidance on Implementation: While the Five Forces Model helps businesses identify industry forces and their impact, it does not provide specific guidance on how to respond or take action. It is up to businesses to interpret the findings and develop appropriate strategies. Without careful consideration and effective implementation, the model's insights may not translate into practical outcomes.

To address these limitations, businesses should consider using the Five Forces Model alongside other strategic frameworks, conducting additional research and analysis, and applying critical thinking to contextualise the findings within their specific industry and organisational context.

What Other Frameworks Work With Five Forces?

Here is a list of other frameworks that complement and work alongside the Five Forces Model:

SWOT Analysis

The SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) analysis provides an internal and external analysis of a business, helping to identify its strengths and weaknesses (internal factors) and opportunities and threats (external factors). SWOT analysis can provide a broader understanding of the business environment and inform strategic decision-making.

PESTEL Analysis

PESTEL analysis examines the macro-environmental factors that influence a business. It helps identify external forces such as regulatory changes, economic trends, social factors, and technological advancements. PESTEL analysis helps businesses understand the broader context in which they operate.

Value Chain Analysis

The Value Chain analysis examines a company's activities and processes to identify areas of competitive advantage and value creation. It helps businesses understand how different activities contribute to their overall value proposition, cost structure, and differentiation. Value Chain analysis assists in identifying opportunities for cost optimization and value-added activities.

Ansoff Matrix

The Ansoff Matrix helps businesses explore growth strategies by analysing product-market combinations. It provides a framework for assessing options such as market penetration, market development, product development, and diversification. The Ansoff Matrix assists in identifying growth opportunities and evaluating the risks associated with each strategy.

Balanced Scorecard

The Balanced Scorecard is a performance measurement framework that translates an organization's strategy into tangible objectives and key performance indicators (KPIs). It helps align strategic goals with operational metrics across different dimensions, including financial, customer, internal processes, and learning and growth. The Balanced Scorecard aids in monitoring and managing the execution of strategy.

Blue Ocean Strategy

The Blue Ocean Strategy encourages businesses to seek uncontested market spaces, known as "blue oceans," where competition is minimal or non-existent. It focuses on creating new market demand through innovation and differentiation, rather than competing in existing market segments. The Blue Ocean Strategy framework helps businesses identify untapped opportunities and develop unique value propositions.

McKinsey 7S Framework

The McKinsey 7S Framework examines seven key elements of an organisation, including strategy, structure, systems, shared values, skills, staff, and style. It helps assess the alignment and interrelationships between these elements and guides organisational change and transformation initiatives.

These frameworks, when used in conjunction with the Five Forces Model, provide a more comprehensive understanding of the business environment, competitive landscape, and strategic options. They offer additional perspectives and insights to support decision-making and strategy formulation.

Recap on Porter's Five Forces Model.

The Five Forces Model analyses the competitive dynamics of an industry. It identifies five key forces that shape industry competition: threat of new entrants, bargaining power of suppliers, bargaining power of buyers, threat of substitute products or services, and intensity of competitive rivalry. By assessing these forces, businesses can understand the attractiveness of an industry, identify potential risks and opportunities, and make informed strategic decisions.

When used with other marketing frameworks, the Five Forces Model helps businesses evaluate their competitive position, assess industry profitability, and develop a marketing strategy to enhance their competitive advantage in the market.

About VCMO

VCMO helps SMEs and portfolio companies with the high-level marketing leadership they need to grow and succeed across the full business lifecycle. Its roster of highly accredited Fractional Chief Marketing Officers brings the expertise, strategy and execution to transform marketing potential into a competitive advantage that delivers predictable revenue and sustainable growth.